A. BIBLIOGRAPHY
McKissack, Patricia C. 2007. THE ALL-I’LL-EVER-WANT CHRISTMAS DOLL. Ill. by Jerry Pinkney. New York, NY: Schwartz. ISBN 9780375937590.
B. PLOT SUMMARY
Set in Pittsburgh during the Great Depression, three sisters are anxiously preparing for Christmas. Christmas always comes to their house, even if Santy Claus didn’t always come. Middle sister Nell is hoping for a Baby Betty doll for Christmas. She proclaims it’s all she’ll ever want. But, big sister Eddy reminds her that they are in a Depression and she is never going to get it. Without her sisters’ knowledge, Nell writes a letter to Santy Claus asking for the doll. Much their surprise, the girls get Baby Betty. However, an argument ensues over who the doll belongs to. After the sisters hold a discussion, they decide that the doll must belong to Nell. Soon, though, Nell realizes how lonely she is without her sisters to play with and asks them to share a tea party with her and Baby Betty. All the rest of Christmas Day the sisters share the doll and have a festive time doing so.
C. CRITICAL ANALYSIS (INCLUDING CULTURAL MARKERS)
This story is a lovely story of a family during Christmas time. Children will relate to the jolly feelings of anticipating and preparing for Christmas. This is another story in which sharing and love are emphasized. This book offers a catalyst for a discussion on how we should treat our loved ones.
The illustrations are delightful. One can almost feel the energy radiating from the characters on each page. A picture of the girls dancing around holding Baby Betty makes the reader ‘feel’ the excitement over receiving a much desired gift.
This is a story that all can relate to. There are virtually no cultural markers in the writing of this story. The only time one cultural marker was noted was in the description of Baby Betty’s appearance-“…the color of chocolate, with rosy cheeks, black curly locks, and thick eyelashes.”
The only cultural marker in the illustrations is in that of the characters. All the characters are African American. The house, clothing, and other details could be from any culture.
D. REVIEW EXCERPTS
Publisher’s Weekly : “In expertly wrought watercolors, Pinkney focuses on how light hits certain objects—voluptuous oranges, a new patchwork quilt, a baby doll's yellow frock—which are some literal bright spots for a family holding onto the positive despite their Depression-era struggles. The newspapers that line the walls and three-to-a-bed sleeping conditions fade, ceding to the clan's Christmas observance. McKissack's story shines as well, homing in on the most straightforward language to convey realistic but difficult situations: “Christmas always came to our house, but Santy Claus only showed up once in a while.”
School Library Journal: “McKissack’s knack for combining historical detail with true-to-life family drama and language is shown to good effect, showcased beautifully by Pinkney’s evocative watercolors, which give a real flavor of the time period. An author’s note at the beginning gives the history of the story. Learning to appreciate what you have and to share what you get are two lessons that never go out of style.”
An ALA Notable Children’s Book
E. CONNECTIONS
Read other stories by Patricia C. McKissack and tell students about her.
Look at other books illustrated by Jerry Pinkney.
Discuss sharing and love.
Have students tell about a time that they received or did not receive something they really wanted for Christmas.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment